Carter’s perfect game?

12:58

Dan Carter comes under the Rugby Retro spotlight as Miles Harrison picks the second Test from the 2005 New Zealand vs Lions series as one of his most memorable games to commentate on

Dan Carter comes under the Rugby Retro spotlight as Miles Harrison picks the second Test from the 2005 New Zealand vs Lions series as one of his most memorable games to commentate on

Daniel Carter’s performance in the second Test of the 2005 British and Irish Lions tour was close enough to perfect that critics and fans alike refer to it as the most dominant individual performance in the modern game.

Fifteen years after the fact, the former All Black spoke exclusively to Sky Sports’ Rugby Retro about the match that changed his career and his life.

Carter cuts through the Lions defence

Carter’s individual tally that night in Wellington revealed a truth that he was unable to immediately grasp. Thirty-three points from two tries, four conversions and five penalties, it was a single match total he would never surpass in an All Black career that would last another 10 years, and include countless Bledisloe Cup wins, multiple Rugby Championship titles, and two World Cups.

“The final whistle went and we were all ecstatic, we’d just won a Lions series and I was so proud of the team. Little did I realise the impact I had on that game,” remembers Carter.

Ma’a Nonu (L) and Carter liked to compare text messages after games

“I went to the changing room, and the boys were celebrating. I always sit next to Ma’a Nonu, and we always have a joke after each Test match about how many text messages you receive. After a test match, Ma’a would probably get 25 or 30 texts, and I’d probably get about the same. It’d always be really close.

“But all of a sudden, I turned on my phone, he was sitting next to me and he was gutted – my phone was just going ‘ding, ding, ding’, all these messages came through, and I clocked up probably over a hundred messages of congratulations, and that was another insight of ‘OK, this game was pretty special’.”

Carter was scintillating against the Lions in the second Test in Wellington

Despite the imperious nature of his performance, Carter’s journey to the number 10 cubicle in that All Black changing room only began in earnest nine months prior, as Graham Henry sought a solution to the long-running, and nationwide, fly-half debate.

“It was only my fourth or fifth Test match in the number 10 jersey, and the previous two years I’d played for the All Blacks I played at second-five eighth (inside centre) alongside a couple of legends of the game, Carlos Spencer and Andrew Mehrtens. They were two completely different players in the style they played, and I felt like I learnt a lot from them.

“The end of year tour in 2004 we travelled to Europe and I got thrown into the leadership role of having to drive this All Black side. I think I was only 22, 23 years old.

“I was relatively young to be doing that and I was still learning, but one thing the coaches showed in me was a real trust in my ability to play in that pivotal position on the biggest stage in a Lions series. I really wanted to prove [my worth] to them for showing faith in selecting me ahead of a couple of icons of the game.”

The Lions were cut to shreds by Carter back in 2005

It would be a position he would never relinquish, and neither Spencer nor Mehrtens would play for the All Blacks again.

After one windy night in Wellington, the world had been introduced to the man they called ‘DC’.

“I didn’t realise the impact it would have after that, but there’s probably two key tournaments in world rugby, and for me they are Rugby World Cups and Lions series’.

Carter beats Shane Williams to the ball in the second Test in Wellington

“If you want to make a name for yourself on the international stage, you have to play well through the Six Nations or Rugby Championship for maybe two, three, four years consistently, or in a Rugby World Cup or a Lions series, you can reach that international fame…through your performance in a single series.”

In Carter’s case, a single match.

“Because it was only my third year playing, I was a bit naïve to how big a Lions series was and [while] people were starting to recognise me around New Zealand, all of a sudden it became a bit more from different parts of the world, ‘OK who is this Dan Carter guy?’ It almost felt like I put my name on the international rugby stage after that series.”

Carter in action for the Kobelco Steelers

He remains on that stage, an international icon of the game, with the spotlight of the Japanese Top League a little less intense than that which has followed him the majority of his career. With club rugby in Japan cancelled for the remainder of this season due to the Coronavirus pandemic, speculation of retirement has been growing.

Time perhaps to sit back and reflect on past achievements?

Carter and Richie McCaw pose with the Webb Ellis Cup in 2015

“I haven’t watched it from start to finish. I’ve seen highlights that pop up everywhere. I was watching some highlights of the game, and all I could think was how greedy I was, I can’t believe how little I passed in that game, it was embarrassing!”

“Who knows? Maybe there’ll be some of these games relived leading into the next Lions series in South Africa, I might sit down with a nice glass of red wine and drag my three sons to watch their old man and see what he used to be able to do.”